Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee (VRBPAC) is a committee appointed by the Food and Drug Administration to review and evaluate scientific data and make recommendations to the FDA when the agency is considering new experimental vaccines for licensure or making changes to existing vaccine licenses. Voting members are appointed by HHS and is designated as FACA HHS #1041. VRBPAC meets approximately four times a year and their public meeting schedule is on kept their website.
Typically, public comment is not taken unless physically present during the meeting held in Rockville, MD.
- May 2023: Written and referenced public comment by NVIC Executive Director Theresa Wrangham opposing the use of Pfizer’s Abrysvo “for the prevention” of RSV in infants from birth through 6 months of age by through vaccination of pregnant individuals". The comment raised concerns about absolute risk reduction for illness and hospitalization provided by the vaccine to infants, and the ability of the small clinical trial size to detect additional vaccine adverse events noted in larger trials for when used in elderly populations. This comment may also be read on Regulations.gov.
- January 2023: Written and referenced public comment by NVIC Co-founder and President Barbara Loe Fisher and Executive Director Theresa Wrangham on future COVID-19 vaccine regimens. Included in the comment are concerns regarding the lack of transparency and access by the public to accurate and complete information about the safety and effectiveness of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines; the fast tracking and FDA’s lowering of the bar on safety and efficacy when granting manufacturers an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) to distribute the vaccines in December 2020; evidence published in the medical literature that mRNA COVID-19 vaccines do not prevent infection with and transmission of SARS-CoV-2, cause myocarditis and other serious health problems, and that mRNA COVID-19 vaccines have generated more adverse event reports to VAERS than any other vaccine. NVIC calls on FDA to request that vaccine manufacturers voluntarily withdraw mRNA COVID-19 vaccines from the market due to inadequate proof of safety and effectiveness.
- November 2015: Oral and referenced written public comment by NVIC Co-founder and President Barbara Loe Fisher on proposed changes to FDA requirements for licensure of vaccines intended for use during pregnancy. She stated that NVIC opposes the FDA retroactively licensing influenza and Tdap vaccines for use in pregnant women and fast tracking RSV and group strep B vaccines to licensure by using small clinical trials; adaptive trial designs; Baysian methods of data analysis; biomarkers and surrogate endpoint measures rather than actual clinical endpoints; or using clinical experience instead of good bench science and randomized controlled clinical trials with long term follow-up to prove effectiveness and safety, and added that FDA standards for proof of vaccine safety and effectiveness must be very high, especially when licensing vaccines targeting pregnant women and their unborn babies.
- September 2015. Oral public comment by Barbara Loe Fisher, NVIC Co-founder and President, at the Sept.15, 2015 meeting of VRBPAC) voicing opposition to the FDA fast-tracking licensure of the MF59 adjuvanted Fluad influenza vaccine for use by seniors over age 65. She stated, “Squalene adjuvants hyper-stimulate the immune system and have been linked with development of autoimmunity, narcolepsy and other chronic disease. Based on the very limited safety and immunogenicity evidence submitted by Novartis, MF59 adjuvanted Fluad vaccine should not be fast tracked to licensure for use by seniors over age 65. She asked the committee, “Why does Fluad need to be fast tracked to licensure for seniors without additional evidence? There is public concern that fast tracking Fluad is really about fast tracking MF59 to licensure so it can be added to lots of new vaccines targeting infants, pregnant women and every American without adequate evidence for safety or effectiveness.”
- February 2012: Oral public comment by Barbara Loe Fisher, NVIC Co-founder and President at the Feb. 29, 2012 meeting of VRBPAC on Licensure Pathways for Pandemic Influenza Vaccines. She stated, “The informed public will be carefully evaluating future pandemic vaccines, including genetically engineered influenza vaccines that contain novel adjuvants, like squalene, which ramp up the immune response. The growing numbers of children and adults with biological vulnerability to suffering immune-mediated brain and immune system dysfunction because they mount atypical inflammatory responses, are particularly wary of novel adjuvants.”
“This places a special responsibility on the FDA to ensure that candidate pandemic influenza vaccines, as well as new vaccine adjuvants not yet licensed in the U.S., are separately tested pre-licensure in animal and human trials. At a minimum, pre-licensure trials should include (1) inactive placebos and participants, who remain unvaccinated or not exposed to the novel adjuvant, as controls; (2) study populations, which reflect all populations to be targeted for vaccine or new adjuvant use post-licensure; (3) at least 60 days follow-up to evaluate safety; 4) administration of the experimental influenza vaccine simultaneously with other vaccines routinely given to children and adults and (5) robust post-licensure evaluation.”
- May 2010: Public comment by NVIC Co-founder and President Barbara Loe Fisher on behalf of NVIC to suspend rotavirus vaccine due to the contamination of seed stocks of rotavirus vaccine with animal virus DNA that was not detected pre or post-licensure is an important wake up call for industry and government. NVIC additionally urged the FDA to (1) explore with vaccine manufacturers technology that does not rely on utilization of mammal, bird, insect or other living cells that can be contaminated with adventitious agents posing a risk to human health; and (2) institute stronger legal requirements for proof that vaccine cell substrates and other materials used for production of seed stocks are free from adventitious agent contamination and remain free throughout the manufacturing process before lots are released for public use; and (3) while vaccines are being thoroughly re-tested for adventitious agent contamination, the FDA should institute stricter labeling standards to fully and clearly inform the public using vaccines about residual adventitious agent content in all vaccines.