A practical guide to making informed vaccination decisions for adults age 50 and older, families and caregivers
You could be standing at a pharmacy counter buying groceries when someone asks, “Would you like your flu, COVID, RSV or shingles vaccine today?” In a doctor’s office, hospital or nursing home, the question may be presented as more of a given fact that you should immediately say “yes” rather than a decision you have the right to take time to thoughtfully consider.
A vaccine is a pharmaceutical product and vaccination is a medical procedure that carries a risk of injury or death that can be greater for some people.
Because we are not all the same and there are individual genetic, epigenetic, and environmental exposure differences among us, we can experience the process of vaccination differently depending upon the type of vaccine and our unique susceptibilities to potential adverse responses to vaccination.
There is no guarantee that a person will not be harmed by a vaccine – or an infectious disease. For example, a healthy 55-year-old and a frail 85-year-old taking prescription medications will not have the same state of health or medical history and may or may not have a similar biological susceptibility to complications from vaccines or infectious diseases.
Federal vaccine recommendations are population-based public health policies and cannot replace an individualized medical assessment when it comes to preventing vaccine reactions, injuries and deaths. One-size-fits-all vaccine policies are not personalized and so many doctors and other medical workers administering vaccines often do not take into account an individual’s current state of health; prior vaccine reactions; genetic and biological differences and susceptibilities; family history of allergic, neurological or autoimmune disorders; or personal values and beliefs.
NVIC does not make vaccine use recommendations. Since 1982, NVIC has worked to prevent vaccine injuries and deaths through public education and to defend the human right to make voluntary, informed vaccination decisions without being coerced or sanctioned for the decision made. The right to informed consent to vaccination belongs to the person being vaccinated or the legal guardian of a person who may be incapable of making informed health decisions. NVIC supports the informed, voluntary vaccination decisions that people make.
This guide will help you ask questions before you agree to be vaccinated or give consent as a guardian for someone in your care to be vaccinated.
For families and caregivers
If an older adult has cognitive impairment or cannot make health care decisions independently, do not allow a medical procedure like vaccination, which comes with risks, to become automatic without your having time to consider all of the facts. Review advance directives, health care proxy or guardianship documents and the person’s known wishes. Confirm who is legally authorized under your state laws to give consent to vaccination before a vaccine is administered.
Being told the name of the disease, like influenza or COVID-19, is not enough. There are different vaccine manufacturers and they market different types of vaccines that contain different ingredients and have different ways of provoking inflammatory responses to produce artificial vaccine acquired immunity.
Ask for the brand name, manufacturer and exact formulation of the vaccine being offered. Vaccines targeting the same disease can contain different ingredients and dosages and have different age indications, warnings, contraindications (reasons to not get the vaccine) and reported adverse reactions. For example, there are two types of COVID-19 shots, an mRNA biological (Pfizer and Moderna) and a protein subunit COVID vaccine (Sanofi), which contain different ingredients with different biological mechanisms for stimulating immune responses.
Questions to ask
Federal law under the 1986 National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act not only requires vaccine administrators to keep a permanent record of the vaccine product name, manufacturer name, vaccine lot number and administration date, but also requires that a Vaccine Information Statement (VIS) published by the CDC containing information about the vaccine and targeted disease must be provided to the person (or guardian of that person) being vaccinated before certain vaccines are administered.
However the VIS is only a brief summary of general information about the vaccine and the targeted disease. The VIS does not contain all the important information, including more detailed information included in the manufacturer product information package insert.
Read the current vaccine manufacturer’s product information package insert and compare it with NVIC’s vaccine ingredient resources and related reporting on vaccine ingredients, such as aluminum and brain health.
The word “effective” can mean different things. A doctor may recommend a vaccine because it is reported to reduce severe disease symptoms or lower the statistical risk of hospitalization, even when the vaccine (or biological product labeled a vaccine) does not reliably prevent infection or transmission.
After you are fully informed, you may decide to use the product to reduce symptoms or your risk of hospitalization if you are infected with the disease the vaccine targets, even though you could still get infected and transmit the infection to others. Or, you may come to the conclusion that if the vaccine does not prevent infection and transmission, you do not want to accept it.
Find out or ask the person recommending the vaccine to explain exactly what the vaccine’s “effectiveness” means and how it was measured.
Senior adults – just like all adults (and children) – are not all the same and do not all react the same way to prescription drugs and vaccines. Find out or ask your doctor how many people your age were included in the vaccine’s clinical trials.
A universal use vaccine recommendation for everyone over a certain age is not evidence that the benefit-risk calculation is the same for every individual in that age group. Vaccine effectiveness can also vary by season, prevalent circulating virus strain, as well as the age of the person being vaccinated.
See related reporting on flu vaccine effectiveness in adults over age 65.
See NVIC’s public comment regarding the federal recommendation for adults at “high risk” for COVID disease complications and those over age 65 to get the COVID shot.
Convenience and saving time for you or your doctor is not the same as evidence that giving multiple vaccines simultaneously on the same day will be safe or effective for you. If several different vaccines, whether singly or in combination shots, are recommended to be given on the same day, ask whether each of those products were studied when administered together to people in your age group and with your specific health conditions.
Being told that you may have a sore arm or feel tired for a day is not the same as being fully informed about potentially serious neurological or other types of reactions associated with a particular vaccine. The type, severity and timing of vaccine reactions vary depending upon the vaccine, such as whether it is a live attenuated viral vaccine, such as shingles vaccine, or inactivated injectable like Tdap vaccine. If you choose to get vaccinated, you should know which warning signs and symptoms of a vaccine reaction require medical attention and how long after vaccination you should watch for them.
Anaphylaxis is a potentially life-threatening allergic reaction. Symptoms can include difficulty breathing or wheezing; swelling of the face, lips, tongue or throat; hives or widespread rash; dizziness, fainting or a sudden drop in blood pressure; and a rapid heartbeat.
The CDC estimates that anaphylaxis occurs at approximately one case per million doses for many vaccines, although anaphylaxis rates vary by product and population. A population based statistic cannot tell you whether you will be the one who has a vaccine reaction.
Before vaccination, ask whether epinephrine injections and airway-management equipment are immediately available in the facility in which you are receiving the vaccine. Tell the provider about the signs and symptoms of allergic reactions you have previously experienced to:
Vaccine Ingredients: Are They Safe?
CDC guidance on preventing and managing adverse reactions.
The act of giving a vaccine can cause injury because of a mistake made by a vaccine administrator even when the vaccine itself is not responsible. Shoulder Injury Related to Vaccine Administration, or SIRVA, can occur when a vaccine administrator improperly inserts an injection needle into certain structures of the shoulder. Unlike ordinary soreness, SIRVA can involve substantial pain, reduced range of motion and difficulty using the arm, often beginning within 48 hours and persisting rather than improving.
Fainting, also called vasovagal syncope, can occur after injections. For an older adult, the resulting fall that causes a head injury or bone fracture may be the greatest danger. The CDC reports that 80 percent of reported fainting episodes occur within 15 minutes of vaccination. Ask to remain seated or lying down during vaccination and to be observed afterward, especially if you have balance problems, low blood pressure or a history of falls.
CDC guidance on post-vaccination fainting.
The current federal Vaccine Injury Table (VIT) in the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) lists specific symptom onset periods for SIRVA and vasovagal syncope involving applicable covered vaccines. The time periods listed are legal criteria used to adjudicate certain vaccine injury compensation claims. They are not medical rules for confirming or dismissing with certainty whether or not the symptoms you experienced after vaccination were caused by the vaccine(s) you received.
Current federal Vaccine Injury Table in the VICP
Guillain-Barré syndrome, or GBS, is an immune mediated neurological disorder in which the immune system attacks the peripheral nerves and affects muscle movement, pain signals, and temperature and touch sensations. Warning signs include tingling or numbness; pain in back or legs; weakness beginning in the legs and moving upward; difficulty walking, speaking or swallowing; changes in eye and facial movement; or breathing difficulty. Severe cases require emergency care. In rare cases, there is permanent partial or full body paralysis, which occurred in some cases of GBS that developed after the national “swine flu” vaccine campaign in 1976.
Seasonal influenza vaccines: CDC states that when an increased risk after influenza vaccination has been observed, it has generally produced approximately one to two additional GBS cases per million doses. A history of GBS within six weeks of a previous flu shot is listed as a precaution in current CDC guidance.
CDC flu vaccine and GBS information.
Shingrix shingles vaccine: FDA required a warning after a study estimated three excess GBS cases per million doses among adults age 65 and older during the 42 days following vaccination. FDA identified an association but stated that available evidence was insufficient to establish causation.
FDA Shingrix safety communication.
Abrysvo and Arexvy RSV vaccines: FDA required warnings to the manufacturer product information package inserts after postmarketing analyses suggested an estimated nine excess GBS cases per million Abrysvo doses and seven per million Arexvy doses among adults age 65 and older during the 42 days following vaccination.
FDA RSV vaccine safety communication.
Government agencies describe these events as rare. But a rare vaccine reaction is not minor to the person whose health is damaged by it. That is why a known association with certain adverse events like GBS and warning signs and symptoms belong in the conversation you have with a doctor or other vaccine administrator before vaccination takes place, not after a reaction or injury has occurred.
Find out or ask whether your personal or family history of GBS or neurological illness is a risk factor for a vaccine reaction.
See NVIC’s related reporting on RSV vaccine labels and GBS risk.
The mRNA COVID-19 shots carry FDA warnings about increased risk for inflammation of the heart (myocarditis and pericarditis). Inflammation of the heart can develop after injection of the mRNA biological provokes strong inflammatory responses that affect the heart muscle or lining of the heart. The highest observed risk has been in males ages 12 through 24 years old, but that does not eliminate the warning for everyone else.
Seek prompt medical attention for chest pain, shortness of breath, a racing or irregular heartbeat, unusual weakness or lightheadedness after vaccination. If you have heart disease, prior myocarditis/pericarditis or recent cardiac symptoms, make sure you and your doctor consider those facts before you make a decision about getting one or more vaccines.
FDA myocarditis and pericarditis safety communication.
Some vaccine reactions begin within minutes. Others develop hours, days or weeks later. Before leaving the doctor’s office, pharmacy or other facility where you have received the vaccine(s) remember to ask:
The timeframes for appearance of vaccine reaction symptoms and related injuries listed in the federal Vaccine Injury Table of the VICP are legal criteria used to adjudicate certain vaccine injury compensation claims. The signs and symptoms listed on the VIT should not be considered to be a medical diagnosis and do not determine whether a specific vaccine reaction symptom falling outside a listed timeframe, should be ignored or dismissed as unrelated to the vaccine(s) administered.
True informed consent is not a quick signature on a form or a quick verbal “yes” given while you are standing at a counter about to be vaccinated. Except in a real medical emergency, you should have access to full information about the complications of infectious diseases and vaccines and enough time to make an educated decision about whether or not to get vaccinated.
Ask for the written manufacturer’s product information package insert. Take it home. Discuss it with a trusted health care professional or other informed person you trust. You have the right to accept, decline or delay vaccination without being bullied, shamed or coerced into making a decision under threat of being denied medical care or suffering any other sanction that violates your informed consent rights or restricts your ability to participate in society.
There can be a difference between a federal government or medical trade group vaccine use recommendation and a legal vaccine requirement in your state. Vaccination policies differ among employers, hospitals, assisted-living communities and nursing homes, and different states have different vaccine laws for school attendance or some types of employment.
If someone tells you a vaccine is mandatory before you can enter a medical or extended care facility, hold a job, or attend college, do not rely on a verbal statement someone has made. Ask for the policy and its legal basis in writing, including the names of the vaccines and doses required; deadlines; consequences for refusal; medical, religious or personal belief exemption accommodation procedures, and right to appeal.
Residents of Medicare- or Medicaid-certified nursing homes have rights outlined by the federal government, such as the right to be informed in advance about proposed medical care interventions, including risks, benefits and alternatives, and to request, refuse or discontinue treatment. A person must be able to exercise those rights without interference, coercion, discrimination or reprisal.
If those rights are not being respected, ask how the refusal and any prior vaccine reaction will be documented. Request contact information for the state survey agency and Long-Term Care Ombudsman.
Federal nursing-home resident rights.
Ask whether a doctor, pharmacy, employer or facility receives financial incentives, performance bonuses, quality-measure credit, reimbursement advantages or other economic or employment benefits connected to maintaining high vaccination rates. Incentives to meet an institutional target should not take the place of offering an individualized assessment to a patient that evaluates the vaccine benefit/risk equation in light of the individual’s state of health and potential genetic, biological and environmental susceptibility to adverse responses to vaccination.
Meeting institutional vaccine uptake goals should never take priority over evaluating your health history and potential high risk factors for experiencing a serious vaccine reaction, or ensuring you are able to freely exercise your human right to voluntary, informed consent to medical risk taking.
If you do experience a vaccine reaction, first seek appropriate medical care. Tell the clinician exactly which vaccine(s) you received, when and where administered, and what specific symptoms you are experiencing and exactly when those symptoms began after vaccination.
Then, you need to protect the written record of what happened to you after vaccination. It is essential that if you experience a vaccine reaction or serious health problem following vaccination, you make sure that the reaction or injury is entered into your permanent written and electronic health record.
Especially if you develop a serious health problem following vaccination, make sure the reaction or injury is entered into your permanent written electronic health record. Do not allow the timing and details of a suspected vaccine reaction to disappear from the medical record.
Request a copy of complete documentation in your medical record, including the timing of vaccination, symptoms, diagnoses, tests and treatment.
The Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) is the national early-warning vaccine reaction monitoring system jointly managed by the CDC and FDA. Anyone can file a report, including the vaccinated person, a caregiver, family member, doctor, pharmacist or medical facility staff member. Health care providers are legally required to report certain adverse events following vaccination and are encouraged to report clinically important serious health problems following vaccination, even if they are uncertain that a vaccine caused those health problems.
A VAERS report does not prove that a vaccine caused an adverse event, and VAERS data cannot determine how often a vaccine adverse event occurs. But if adverse events that occur after vaccination are never reported to the government, they become invisible to those operating VAERS and, because VAERS reports are transparently available for online viewing by the public, vaccine-related adverse events that are never reported become invisible to the public as well.
If you file a vaccine reaction report in VAERS, save a written record of the VAERS identification number and submit follow-up records about the reaction or injury when appropriate.
Search vaccine adverse event reports to VAERS through NVIC’s MedAlerts database.
Filing a VAERS report does not automatically file a vaccine injury compensation claim for you in the VICP and does not stop a claim filing deadline from running. The vaccine injury compensation system is complicated, and not every vaccine recommended by the CDC for older adults is covered by the same vaccine injury compensation program.
For example, seasonal influenza and pneumococcal conjugate vaccines are covered by the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP), while shingles and pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccines are not. COVID-19 shot claims are handled through the Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program (CICP), which has different eligibility requirements and filing deadlines.
Do not assume that a doctor, hospital, pharmacy or government agency will warn you before time runs out for filing your vaccine injury compensation claim. Verify the applicable vaccine injury compensation program and deadline for filing immediately after you experience a vaccine reaction or injury, and consult a qualified vaccine-injury attorney if you believe you may have a claim.
Review HRSA’s VICP filing information, HRSA’s CICP filing information and NVIC’s vaccine injury compensation resources.
For too many senior adults, vaccination has become an automatic part of a pharmacy visit, annual physical, hospital discharge or admission to a long-term care facility with no exceptions and no questions asked or answered. Vaccine use should never be automatic.
Ask the vaccine administrator what vaccine(s) will be given and why the vaccine or multiple vaccines are being recommended for you. Ask what is known and not known about the vaccine(s) potential benefits and risks, what alternatives exist and what choices you have if you delay or decline.
Keep a written and electronic copy of your medical and vaccination records. Document prior vaccine reactions. Bring a trusted family member or patient advocate if you need support at the facility where the vaccine(s) will be given. Asking questions should not be viewed as causing trouble or refusing care. You have rights when it comes to medical risk taking.
If you choose to be vaccinated, that decision should be made because you understand the potential benefits and accept the potential risks. If you choose to delay or decline a vaccine, that decision should be respected, too. No doctor, pharmacist, employer, government official or long-term care facility should use fear, coercion or punishment to make the decision for you.
NOTE: This educational information is not to be considered individualized medical or legal advice. Product labeling, federal and state recommendations and laws can change. Speak with one or more trusted health care professionals and confirm current information for the exact product being recommended and individual circumstances involved to make a fully informed decision about vaccination.