On October 6, 2020, an international coalition of scientists, doctors and medical professionals created and signed a document expressing grave concern regarding the potential negative repercussions of lockdown measures imposed by governments in the wake of COVID-19 and called for a global policy change to what they call focused protection.
152 The document, entitled The Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), was named for the Massachusetts town where organizers gathered and in which the petition was signed.153
The creators of the GBD expressed concerns that “current lockdown policies are producing devastating effects on short and long-term public health,” including fewer healthcare screening visits, worse outcomes for cardiovascular disease and other pre-existing conditions, and serious effects on mental health. Stating that vulnerability to death from COVID-19 is more than a thousand-fold higher in the old and infirm than the young
and further, that for children, COVID-19 is less dangerous than many other harms, including influenza,
the authors recommended that measures be put in place to protect vulnerable segments of society, while allowing all others to immediately return to normal life.154
Specifically, they suggested that nursing home staff be limited to those with acquired immunity, staff rotations minimized and staff and visitors frequently tested. Groceries and other essentials should be delivered to elderly who live in the community and the vulnerable should interact with people outside whenever possible. For everyone else, the authors recommended that:155
- businesses and restaurants should open fully;
- schools and universities should immediately reopen for in-person attendance, and offer all extracurricular activities;
- sports, art, music, and other group events should resume; and
- young low-risk adults should return to work instead of working from home.
Dr. Fauci and former NIH Director Dr. Francis Collins, however, called the authors fringe scientists
and reported that if public health officials had followed the recommendations made in the GBD, more infections, hospitalizations, and deaths would have occurred.156
Rationale for Lockdowns Questioned
In mid-October 2020, the WHO’s Special Envoy, Dr. David Nabarro, stated that lockdowns should not be used as the primary method to control COVID-19 outbreaks. Dr. Nabarro noted that lockdowns will increase poverty and hunger globally and that it is likely that within a year, child malnutrition and poverty will double. Additionally, a study conducted in May 2020 reported that the anxiety and stress of lockdowns will likely “destroy seven times the years of life that lockdowns potentially save.”
In January 2021, the European Journal of Clinical Investigation published a peer-reviewed paper conducted by Stanford University researchers that reported that their study failed “to find an additional benefit of stay-at-home orders and business closures.”
In an interview aired on May 20, 2021, former White House COVID-19 advisor, Dr. Scott Atlas, called the COVID-19 associated lockdowns a “heinous abuse of power” and did nothing to protect the most vulnerable populations at risk for the illness. Atlas criticized the response of public health officials, and stated that:
“the lockdowns failed, they still failed to protect the people who are high risk, and the lockdowns destroyed and killed. Many other people destroyed families, sacrificed our children out of fear for adults—even though the children do not have significant risk. And we didn’t care as a country. We kept them out of school.”
The CDC reported that from March 2020 to March 2021, 96,779 drug overdoses occurred in the United States, an increase of nearly 30 percent from one year prior and was noted to be the largest single year increase ever in the U.S. National Institute on Drug Abuse Director Dr. Nora Volkow noted that the COVID-19 pandemic had “created a devastating collision of health crises in America.” The US reported a record number of drug overdoses in 2022, with 109,680 drug related deaths reported.
More than 400 published studies have reported on the failure of COVID-19 lockdown and masking policies to slow transmission or reduce deaths. A review of the available literature and a meta-analysis on the effects of lockdowns on COVID-19 mortality conducted by the Johns Hopkins Institute for Applied Economics, Global Health, and the Study of Business Enterprise published in January 2022 reported that the lockdowns in the U.S. and Europe reduced mortality rates by only 0.2 percent on average. Shelter in place orders were reported to have only reduced mortality rates by 2.9 percent. Non-pharmaceutical interventions were reported to have no noticeable effects on reducing COVID-19 mortality.