Most states that implemented lockdown orders in March began reopening by early May 2020. Reopening plans varied by state, but most continued to restrict crowd size and imposed additional restrictions including face mask mandates. A small number of states, however, chose not to issue lockdown orders. These included Nebraska, Iowa, Arkansas, North and South Dakota. In South Dakota, Governor Kristi Noem refused to implement restrictive measures and stated:
“Ultimately it is the people themselves that are primarily responsible for their safety,” Noem said. “They are the ones who are entrusted expansive freedoms. They are free to exercise their rights to work, worship, and to play or to stay at home and to conduct social distancing.”
Noem was widely criticized, but stood by her decision, stating that it was her duty to uphold the Constitution.
According to a report published by the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) on October 20, 2020, South Dakota was ranked 40th in death rates, with 182.3 deaths per 1 million population. In contrast, New Jersey, which issued strict lockdown orders that included penalties, fines, and even jailtime for violations, was ranked first in death rates, at 1,791.6 per 1 million population.
A working paper published in April 2022 by the National Bureau of Economic Research concluded that lockdowns had essentially no impact on decreasing COVID-19 deaths, but led to significant educational and economic damage. On a state by state basis, Utah, Nebraska, and Vermont were rated highest for their response to COVID-19, while the District of Columbia, New York, and New Jersey were given the lowest rating.
In the summer of 2021, the state of Florida experienced a surge in COVID-19 cases, hospitalization, and deaths, and was among the most impacted states in the nation. Government officials, however, chose not to implement any restrictive policies such as mask mandates or business closures. Instead, the state focused on making vaccines accessible to individuals who wanted them, and opened monoclonal antibody treatment centers throughout the state. Florida governor Ron DeSantis reported that the spike was seasonal and would wane. Additionally, DeSantis stated that this strategy would work to defeat the pandemic. By the end of October 2021, Florida had one of the lowest rates of COVID-19 cases and deaths.
In contrast, New York State recorded the highest one-day case count of COVID-19 in mid-December 2021, despite having one of the highest vaccination rates in the country.