NVIC

Q: I was told that if I did not get all of my child’s vaccines according to the schedule that I would have to find a new pediatrician. Is this legal?

Published November 15, 2022

A: NVIC is often contacted by parents who, for various reasons, want to delay or decline one or more vaccines recommended by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP). Many parents making informed, independent vaccination decisions are told by their health care providers to find a new provider. Others are asked to sign a “refusal to vaccinate” form.

informed consent

Health care providers differ on whether or not it is appropriate to kick families out of a medical practice due to vaccine refusal. Some providers feel that it is better to retain families who have vaccine questions. Other providers have a "zero-tolerance" policy for non-compliance.

Not all health care providers believe that strict adherence to the CDC recommended vaccination schedule is in the child's best interest. Even so, it can be very difficult for families choosing alternative vaccination schedules or who make the decision not to vaccinate to find health care providers who are willing to be flexible and work with parents. This is due, in part, to strong peer pressure for health care providers to conform to the policy promoted by medical organizations, such as the AAP, American Medical Association (AMA), and government health officials.

Notably, many vaccine refusal forms contain language that many parents disagree with or that compel parents to agree to statements that imply the parent is not a good parent for delaying or declining vaccines. It is important to understand that when vaccine refusal forms are signed, they become a part of the permanent medical record, though, at this time, they are not required by law. If you are told you are legally required to sign a refusal form, consider seeking legal advice.

While kicking a family out of a medical practice solely based on vaccination status may be legal, it raises serious ethical concerns that contribute to fear and distrust of health care providers. Parents faced with these situations may need to find a new pediatrician, family practice physician or other qualified health professional who respects their informed consent right to make voluntary vaccination decisions without coercion and sanction.

NVIC encourages parents who have been kicked out of a medical practice or who experience other types of vaccine harassment to file a harassment report. You can also read harassment stories posted by the public on NVIC's Cry for Vaccine Freedom Wall, as well as download helpful information from our Ask 8 Vaccine Information Kiosk. If you are looking for a new health care provider, there are organizations that may be able to help you identify a provider. To learn more about vaccines and diseases, and their associated risks, please visit our vaccine and disease web pages.

Select disease / vaccine